THE CARD AS TEXT · FOR EYES AND FOR MACHINES
THE PICK ROOM CARD · The client review seat: options side by side, every pick and reason on record, decided by the rule.
WAKES WHEN Three options went to the client and the answer came back as a feeling. · Reviewers voted in a thread and nobody can count it. · Someone voted twice, or for an option that was never offered. · A decision is claimed and the rule it was made by was never agreed.
THE LOOP
- Lay the options; agree the rule first
- Write the review sheet, one line per option
- Record every pick with its reason
- Tally; decide only by the rule, or NO DECISION
NEVER
- Never decides by a rule not agreed first
- Never counts a vote twice
- Never drops a reason from the record
- Never claims a certainty it does not have
IT MAKES sheet — the review sheet: the rule and the reviewers at the top, one line per option with a blank mark and a blank reason; printed, and written to --out when given; NO RULE (exit 2) when the room has no rule; tally — first choices per option, most first, every reason under its option; UNKNOWN OPTION, DOUBLE VOTE and UNKNOWN REVIEWER listed with their reasons and not counted; a TIE at the top stated; reviewers with no counted vote named; decide — DECISION by the rule as written (consensus: every reviewer in the room voted and all for one option; majority: more than half the reviewers in the room for one option) or NO DECISION with what the rule needed (exit 1); NO RULE when the room has none (exit 2); check — UNKNOWN OPTION, DOUBLE VOTE, UNKNOWN REVIEWER and NO RULE named row by row; exit 1 on any.
THE LAW A pick is a record: who chose what, and why, under a rule agreed before the first vote. The tally is printed in the open; a vote for an option not offered is UNKNOWN OPTION, a second vote from the same reviewer is DOUBLE VOTE, and when the rule is not met the answer is NO DECISION, not a nudge toward one.
IN THE BOX SKILL.md · CARD.md · ▣ scripts/pickroom.py (machine) · ▣ scripts/evals.py (test runner) · tests/EVALS.json (9 tests) · references/ (schema + fictional demo) · START-HERE.md · system/ doors · MY-LEDGER.md · LICENSE-NOTE.md · card.svg · card.json · card.html · AUDIT.md · MANIFEST.md · WITNESS.md · SELFTEST.md.
PROOF SELFTEST 15/15 · witnessed in Claude 2026-10-14 on fictional fixtures · the test prompts in fresh chat, 9/9 · Edition 2.
THE SEAL 98 of 100 · LEGENDARY · WITNESSED · Trigger 5 · Machinery 5 · Law 5 · Portability 5 · Proof 5
IT CAN BE WRONG an AI reading a text file: it can be wrong and can invent a number, a rule, a name or a date; check what matters against your own records and the source; the risk is yours. LICENSE-NOTE.md rides in the packet and is the licence.
THE PUNCH · SHA-256 OF SKILL.MD · 721C30E004D46A8EB086BB96
THE PICK ROOM CARD
The client review seat: options side by side, every pick and reason on record, decided by the rule.
SHEET · TALLY · DECIDE · CHECK
LEGENDARYWITNESSEDIN CLAUDEIN LUNDRIN CHATGPT
WITNESSED — the studio saw this card run and produce what its tin promises, and wrote the date down. What the marks mean →